It’s been a long time coming, but shellshape (my tiling window manager extension for gnome-shell) is finally available via extensions.gnome.org. Get it while it’s hot!
You’ll need the bleeding edge (3.4.1) version of gnome-shell, as it’s the first version that allows normal extensions to register new keybindings. If you’re stuck on 3.4 you can still use the 0launch method described on the shellshape homepage.
Today I released the first version of shellshape, a tiling window manager plugin for gnome-shell. It’s definitely pre-alpha software, and currently requires a custom fork of the mutter window manager. I’ve had some trouble getting it running due to awful packaging things (I now know far too much about dynamic linking path resolution on linux), but it should work, at least on Fedora 15. Please give it a go if you use gnome-shell - and if not, there’s more information and a demo video at the above link.
It’s got a long way to go - there are certainly bugs, and some features aren’t done right yet. But it works, and that’s pretty exciting to me after working towards it on and off for about four months.
I’ve been using xmonad (with a slightly modified bluetile setup) for about a year now, and it’s been pretty great. But I still feel locked in to its grid sometimes, and miss the direct manipulation that a “normal” window manager (like metacity) provides - specifically allowing quick movement and resizing by using alt + mouse dragging. Bluetile has the option of floating windows, but actually moving or resizing them is so cumbersome that it’s not really worth it. I also sometimes wish that my windows could overlap, so that (while still tiled) a window can extend beyond the bounds of its tile if I want it to.
I also am a sucker for shiny things, and xmonad is far from a shiny thing (in terms of graphics). I tried out gnome-shell yesterday, and while buggy, it is exceedingly shiny. And considering that gnome-shell will not allow alternate window managers (that was a surprise to me), I have put some thought into what my ideal window manager would look like.
I’m keen to try and implement this somewhere. It’s unlikely to be xmonad, as I want builtin compositing support (and haskell is a great language, but I can barely figure out how to configure xmonad, let alone extend it). So I’m wondering if the following can be done as a plugin to either gnome-shell or mutter. Hopefully gnome-shell, as I can stomach javascript hacking a lot easier than compiling C extensions.
Also, if people know of an existing project (with compositing!) that has these sorts of features, I’d be interested to know - I don’t want to have to reinvent the wheel, but it seems like most tiling window managers are too rigid and keyboard-based for me, while most “grid” extensions to floating window managers are too manual.
So, here’s the plan:
I’ve recently started using bluetile instead of compiz, and I think I’m going to stick with it. Bluetile is a tiling window manager, but it’s not like all those other tiling window managers*:
* well okay, it is like those other tiling window managers. Specifically, it’s built on xmonad. But it presents a simple veneer over the vast complication that is xmonad (I should know, I tried to configure it just last week ;)).
Bluetile is, sadly, notoriously difficult to install. But there are good guides around, I used this one for ubuntu karmic.
The good news is, bluetile has recently been merged back into the xmonad mainline. And xmonad is apt-gettable (at least on ubuntu). So in theory, the next release of xmonad will make it pretty easy to run in bluetile mode, without having to compile-your-own-window-manager (which certainly does not make for a gentle learning curve). If anyone is considering playing around with alternate window managers, it’s definitely worth your while to give bluetile a go.
..in which I propose a potentially-new window management feature, and hope that somebody has already done it so that I won’t have to…